Dane County Ruling Stops Far Short of Law Forward’s Sweeping Bid to Rewrite Wisconsin’s Absentee Ballot Rules

A Dane County, Wisconsin, judge today declined to adopt the sweeping rule Law Forward sought in Honig v. WEC, No. 2026CV1463. Instead, the court confined its ruling to a single, very narrow set of facts and circumstances.

Law Forward asked the court to declare that “Wisconsin election statutes cannot be interpreted or applied to disenfranchise voters due to errors by election officials.” That language would have reached every election statute on the books and any error by any official, however it arose and whatever the voter’s own role. 

The court did not grant that request. Its ruling covers one scenario: an absentee voter who completed the ballot correctly and returned it to the municipal clerk in time to reach the polling place by 8:00 p.m., where the ballot missed that deadline solely because of an election official’s act or omission. In the court’s words, “The holding of this Decision is limited to the category described above.”

Wisconsin voters Billie Johnson and Kendall Post intervened in the case, with the support of the Center for Election Confidence, to oppose Law Forward’s broad request. The court agreed with this approach and devoted an entire section to the very limits Johnson and Post requested as an alternative to dismissal.