A recent syndicated column from Hans von Spakovsky and J. Christian Adams (Voter Rolls — Public Records or State Secrets?) highlights the Supreme Court fight over voter-roll transparency in Public Interest Legal Foundation v. Nago (No. 26-98). The commentary explains that the Ninth Circuit held Hawaii’s statewide voter-registration list is not subject to the National Voter Registration Act’s public-disclosure provision, while another federal appellate court has taken the opposite view. The column presents the resulting circuit split as an important question for the Supreme Court because it determines whether citizens and organizations can independently examine statewide voter rolls and evaluate list-maintenance practices.
The column emphasizes the NVRA’s requirement that states make available records concerning programs and activities used to keep voter lists accurate and current. The authors argue that statewide voter files are central to that transparency because public access allows outside organizations to identify duplicate, deceased, or otherwise inaccurate registrations and assess whether election officials are maintaining the rolls effectively. They contend that the Ninth Circuit’s narrower interpretation prevents meaningful independent review of voter-list maintenance in the states within that circuit.
Von Spakovsky and Adams’s column specifically identified the Center for Election Confidence, Judicial Watch, and the Honest Elections Project as organizations that have joined PILF in asking the Supreme Court to resolve the split and grant review. CEC’s amicus brief, filed by former U.S. Solicitor General Paul Clement, argues that the statewide voter file is both a product of and evidence concerning list-maintenance activities and therefore falls within the NVRA’s public-inspection mandate. CEC urges the Court to grant PILF’s petition and clarify that the NVRA requires meaningful public access to records needed to evaluate whether voter rolls are accurate and current.
