The Daily Signal highlighted the Center for Election Confidence’s (CEC) amicus brief in Public Interest Legal Foundation v. Nago, identifying the case as one of several significant legal disputes that could come before the U.S. Supreme Court. The article explained that the case could determine whether states must provide access to voter-registration records under the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA) and “could affect how much access election-integrity organizations have to state voter registration information.” The Daily Signal specifically identified CEC, along with the Honest Elections Project and Judicial Watch, as organizations who filed amicus briefs in the case.
The dispute arose after the Public Interest Legal Foundation requested Hawaii’s statewide voter-registration list in April 2023. The Daily Signal reported that Hawaii denied access under state law restricting use of the voter roll and has maintained that requests for voter-registration information should instead be directed to individual counties. PILF argues that those restrictions conflict with the NVRA’s public-disclosure requirements. The case therefore presents the Supreme Court with a dispute over the extent to which federal law requires public access to records used in maintaining voter-registration lists.
CEC’s amicus brief urges the Supreme Court to grant review of the Ninth Circuit’s decision. Represented by former U.S. Solicitor General Paul Clement, CEC argues that the NVRA’s public-inspection provision encompasses the statewide voter file because access to that information allows citizens and organizations to evaluate whether election officials are maintaining accurate and current voter lists. CEC maintains that excluding the voter file from public inspection would limit an important means of independently evaluating state list-maintenance practices.
