The 6th Circuit stayed a preliminary injunction preventing Ohio from enforcing House Bill 54’s documentary proof-of-citizenship requirement in the State’s Bureau of Motor Vehicles voter-registration process. A divided panel concluded that Ohio was likely to succeed in vacating the injunction on threshold jurisdictional grounds and that the remaining stay factors favored allowing the state to enforce H.B. 54 while the appeal proceeds.
The Center for Election Confidence (CEC), joined by the Honest Elections Project (HEP), previously filed an amicus brief urging the 6th Circuit to grant Ohio’s stay motion. CEC and HEP argued that the district court lacked jurisdiction because the plaintiffs’ claims had become moot and, separately, that the district court misread Section 5 of the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA) in a manner that intruded upon Ohio’s constitutional authority to determine and enforce voter qualifications.
The Sixth Circuit majority closely tracked CEC and HEP’s jurisdictional arguments. Red Wine & Blue had relied on two identified members, Margaret Dutcher and Giana Fazio, to establish associational standing. But after the lawsuit began, both obtained Ohio driver’s licenses and registered to vote or updated their voter registrations. CEC and HEP argued that because both women had already presented citizenship documentation to the BMV, H.B. 54 would not subject them to the challenged requirement again, leaving Red Wine & Blue without standing.
The majority reached substantially the same conclusion. It determined that Dutcher and Fazio’s standing to obtain prospective relief “appears lacking” because neither woman’s alleged injury resulted from H.B. 54’s proof-of-citizenship requirement. Instead, both initially failed to complete their BMV transactions because of independent defects in their driver’s-license documentation. The court further reasoned that even if they had suffered a cognizable injury, both had since registered to vote and their citizenship information was now contained in the BMV database, making future exposure to H.B. 54 unlikely.
The panel also picked up CEC and HEP’s argument concerning the “capable of repetition yet evading review” exception to mootness. CEC and HEP had challenged the district court’s conclusion that the controversy remained live because some unidentified future Ohio resident might encounter H.B. 54. The amicus brief emphasized that the exception requires a reasonable expectation that the same complaining party will again face the challenged action and argued that Lawrence v. Blackwell did not eliminate that requirement merely because a case concerns elections. The majority likewise rejected reliance on unidentified persons who may face difficulty registering to vote in the future, explaining that the relevant repetition must concern “the complaining party—not ‘another member of the public.’” It similarly distinguished Lawrence, reasoning that its relaxed treatment of election disputes applied because the same voter and candidate could reasonably expect to encounter the challenged rule again.
That portion of the order particularly parallels CEC and HEP’s brief. CEC and HEP argued that Lawrence required a reasonable expectation that the “same political actor(s)” would again face the restriction and that its reference to future Ohio candidates or voters did not eliminate the Supreme Court’s same-complaining-party rule. CEC and HEP further emphasized that Red Wine & Blue had not identified another member who would encounter H.B. 54 and that speculation about an unidentified person who may, at some point in the future, apply to register to vote could not maintain a live Article III controversy.
The majority did not, however, reach CEC and HEP’s separate merits arguments concerning the NVRA and Ohio’s constitutional authority over voter qualifications. CEC and HEP had argued that the Constitution gives States authority to set and enforce voter qualifications, that Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona distinguishes voter qualifications from Congress’s authority over the “Times, Places and Manner” of congressional elections, and that constitutional-avoidance and federalism principles favor a narrow construction of NVRA Section 5. The majority expressly stated that because Ohio had shown a sufficient likelihood of success on threshold grounds, it “need not address the merits of the district court’s NVRA analysis.” Accordingly, the stay does not resolve the ultimate preemption question or adopt CEC and HEP’s constitutional and federalism arguments.
The court concluded that the remaining stay factors also favored Ohio, emphasizing the administrative burdens and voter confusion that could result from changing Ohio’s voter-registration procedures shortly before the November election. It therefore granted Ohio’s motion and stayed the district court’s preliminary injunction pending appeal. The order reaches the result CEC and HEP urged and closely tracks CEC and HEP’s central jurisdictional argument: the district court’s prospective injunction rested on identified members whose alleged injuries no longer supplied a sufficient Article III basis for that relief. The court will have the opportunity to consider CEC and HEP’s broader arguments concerning the NVRA and the States’ constitutional authority over voter qualifications at the merits stage of the appeal.
The Center for Election Confidence thanks Jason Torchinsky, Elizabeth Price Foley, and Steve LaRussa of Holtzman Vogel for their representation in this matter.
