CEC Supports Restoration of Citizenship Question on 2030 Census

The Center for Election Confidence (CEC) urged the Census Bureau to restore a citizenship question to the 2030 Census short-form questionnaire in comments submitted to the U.S. Department of Commerce. The decennial census has not asked all respondents about citizenship since 1950.

CEC recommended that the Census Bureau adopt the citizenship question currently used by the American Community Survey for the short-form Census questionnaire, pairing it with a legal-status follow-up and supplementing responses with a review of available administrative records. This combined approach would improve citizenship determinations and allow the Bureau to publish block-level citizen voting-age population figures with federal confidentiality safeguards. “One person, one vote protects voters against vote dilution,” CEC explained. These data would help States assess voting power when drawing legislative districts, if they choose. CEC also urged the Bureau to clarify that citizenship and legal-status questions are mandatory.

CEC supports the proposed rule’s emphasis on an accurate census and its exclusion of unlawfully present persons from the population used to apportion seats in the United States House of Representatives. “An error in the census thus becomes an error in representation that endures for a decade,” CEC explained. Because of the weighty import of such a change, CEC urged the Bureau to explain its departure from the 2020 residence criteria and publish status-determination procedures before 2030 so that “States, Congress, and the public evaluate the method before it is used.”

CEC examined two approaches to determining usual residence: records reflecting ties to a State or days spent there. Records can capture enduring ties but may be incomplete or outdated; counting days offers a uniform standard but may overlook those ties for service members, students, prisoners, seasonal residents, and others with special circumstances who may be treated as residents of a particular state despite spending time elsewhere. CEC weighed both methods’ strengths and weaknesses without endorsing one exclusively and identified voter registration records as a possible way to reconcile them.

The comments further urge the Bureau to protect population-count accuracy at every geographic level, including census blocks used for redistricting. CEC opposed disclosure-avoidance methods that artificially change counts, recommended limiting count imputation to a last resort, and called for earlier publication of accuracy data, preservation of count-correction procedures, and stronger independent oversight. Individual information should remain protected under federal census-confidentiality law without compromising the counts.

To strengthen public confidence in elections, CEC urged the Bureau to restore the citizenship question and adopt these safeguards so that the 2030 Census produces accurate, transparent information and apportionment.